Why selling is hard to do - Diana Clement writes for RaboPlus

Why selling is hard to do

The ability to sell is crucial for investors. Even long term investors need to sell sometimes because buy and hold doesn't mean buy and never sell.

Reasons to sell could include:

The problem with selling is that we're programmed to avoid it. Researcher Terrance Odean found back in the 1990s that instead of cutting losses short and letting profits run, most investors do the opposite. It's not surprising, therefore, if you find yourself thinking:

The first is a "buy and hope" strategy and the second two are based on flawed thinking. Investing should never be about emotions. If you can't keep your emotions out of your portfolio then you really need some assistance.

I've read some great tips if you have trouble selling. They include:

  • Always write down the reasons you are buying an investment. If it no longer matches your strategy then it's a good time to think about selling
  • Set "guide" sell prices when you buy
  • Get to know yourself and what drives you to sell winners and keep losers

The Motley Fool, one of my favourite investing websites gives four triggers to sell:

  1. Valuation. If you've bought undervalued investments then once they reach fair valuation it's time to sell.
  2. Fundamental changes in the underlying business
  3. Challenges to your investing thesis.
  4. Better places for your money - as mentioned above.

Amongst the mistakes we make when selling investments is making the decision on whether they are in profit or loss. It may seem logical, but the decision should be made on what the future holds for that investment (as well as our current situations) rather than the price it was bought at.

Finally, to take advantage of any of this advice you need to track investments- which means keeping details in a spreadsheet, or portfolio monitoring tool.

Diana Clement

2 Comments

Comment by Russ on 21-07-2009 10:33


All good stuff Diana - and certainly tracking your investments is key. Can you recommend a good comprehensive portfolio monitoring tool that will cope with domestic and international investments and calculate their reeturn on an annualised basis?

Comment by Diana Clement on 28-07-2009 10:34


Thanks for your comments Russ. Sadly there are a lot of those tools available on the Internet that don’t include NZ-based shares, so are next to useless if that is the bulk of your portfolio. There is one I have found that looks good. But I haven’t given it a trial run. The website is sharesight.co.nz. I would be interested to hear if anyone has tried it and what they think.
It’s a shame that Morningstar (which has a NZ website) doesn’t offer the same portfolio that it does overseas. I got completely sidetracked whilst looking at the shared portfolios on Morningstar.com: http://discuss.morningstar.com/NewSocialize/portfoliosharing/SharedPortfoliosList.aspx


Submit a comment*:

 
* All comments are moderated and posted live during working hours.
Join Rabo - Apply online now